Mandatory Genetic Editing For Children to be Established Within 10 Years, Expert Claims

Would You Have Your Children’s Genetics Changed to Make Them Hyper Intelligent?

ZOLTAN ISTVAN | MotherBoard

While Time magazine recently chose President-Elect Donald Trump as its Person of the Year, CRISPR gene editing pioneers were a runner-up choice. Few innovations in the last millennium carry such transformative prospects as the ability to edit our own genome and make ourselves into fundamentally something else. Some experts think genetic editing might be the key to curing all disease and achieving perfect health.

Unlike other epic scientific advances—like the 1945 explosion of the first atomic bomb in New Mexico—the immediate effect of genetic editing technology is not dangerous. Yet, it stands to be just as divisive to humans as the 70-year proliferation of nuclear weaponry. On one hand, you have secular-minded China and its scientists leading the gene editing revolution, openly modifying the human genome in hopes of improving the human being. On the other hand, you have a soon-to-be broadly Republican US administration and Congress that appear to be strongly Christian—conservatives who often insist humans should remain just as God created them.

The immediate effect of genetic editing technology is not dangerous. Yet, it stands to be just as divisive to humans as the 70-year proliferation of nuclear weaponry.

Therein lies a great coming conflict, one that I’m sure will lead to street protests, riots, and civil strife—the kind described explicitly in my novel The Transhumanist Wager, where a religious-fundamentalist government shuts down extreme science in the name of conservatism. The playing field of geopolitics is pretty simple: If China or another country vows to increase its children’s intelligence via genetic editing (which I estimate they will be able to do in 5-10 years time), and America chooses to remain “au naturel” because they insist that’s how God made them, a conflict species-deep will quickly arise. If this scenario seems too bizarre to happen, just consider the Russian Olympic track and field team that was banned in the recent 2016 Games for supposed doping.

It’s quite possible the same accusatory flavor of “banning” could happen between China and America in the game of life—between its workers, its politicians, is people, its artists, and its media. I wonder if America—approximately 70 percent who identify as Christians—will put up with beings who modified themselves by science to be smarter and more functional entities.

This type of idea takes racism and immigration to a whole new level. Will America close off its borders, its jobs, its schools, and its general openness to the world to stay pure, old-fashioned human? Will we stop trading, befriending, and even starting families with those who are modified?

In short, will genetic editing start a new cold war? One that bears much finger pointing and verbal reprimands, including the use of derogatory terms like mutants, cyborgs, and transhumanists. Think the videogame Dues Ex, but with modified people taking all the best jobs.

So, now that we know what can happen if America won’t embrace the most important science to emerge this century, how can we avoid it?

First—and this is wishful thinking, since 100 percent of the US Congress and the Supreme Court appear to be religious at the moment—is we could just embrace genetic editing and be better at it than the Chinese. This is the exact scenario I suggest. Yes, it will lead to a place where beings are similar to those in Star Wars andStar Trek, but after all, we love those movies because we want to reach that super-science age. And in the long run, such evolution of the species is inevitable anyway, so long as we don’t kill ourselves first in a nuclear war or an environmental catastrophe.

In a second scenario, America could focus more on technology and less on biology and genetics. On my recent 4-month long Immortality Bus tour across America, I found conservative people seem more inclined to use tech accessories or wear a special headset that would make them smarter (for example, by connecting their thoughts Matrix-style into the cloud and AI)—as opposed to structurally changing their brains, as the Chinese likely will do. America could innovate that accessory tech that would keep us ahead of the biological modifications of other nations. I’ll accept that—reluctantly—if the first scenario I presented is a no-go.

A third way—and this is the blatant transhumanist nightmare—is we could establish a non-modification policy across all countries, similar to how we have created the Paris Treaty for climate change or rules of war that ban chemical weapons. The major nations of the world, sensing a significant global legal issue in genetic editing, could come together as a species and criminalize the science.


The front desk of BGI-Tianjin. BGI is one of the leading genetic research companies in China and the world, and is actively pursuing the genetic basis of human intelligence. Image: Wei ta – Imaginechina/Associated Press

To some extent, this has already happened, because as soon as the world realized the Chinese had experimented on the human genome, calls were made to put a stop on some of this science. Such a reaction is not dissimilar from what George W. Bush did with stem cells when his religious values made him shut down federal funding on all but a tiny portion of the research in America. Stem cells have since been shown to be one of the most important medical applications in the world, and those lost years of science have potentially negatively affected millions of lives.

Sadly, the third option of a general or even partial moratorium on genetic editing will surely harm innovation. The great thing with gene editing is we can likely do many wondrous things with it, such as potentially cure cancer, halt aging, grow better organs, and overcome disability by better repairing ourselves. Beyond making ourselves superhuman, we can simply make ourselves better fit for Earth, including dealing with a changing environment.

I also don’t think the third option will work in the long run. More than ever, science is the hands of individuals, who can buy amazing bio-testing kits on eBay for just a $1000—as well as incredibly powerful computers to analyze the data. Citizen scientists would just create the new gene editing tech and begin doing it themselves—perhaps more dangerously had the government not been overseeing the research from the start.

I argue for the first path. Let’s allow good, old-fashioned scientific competition with China to proceed. Let’s see which country can create the best enhancements for their citizenry, and let’s share the best of our work with one another in the end to make it so all peoples are as equal as possible. If we’re too closed-minded about such radical science, we might find ourselves embroiled in a state of hostile speciation, where another new cold war swallows a generation.

 

Zoltan Istvan is a futurist, author of The Transhumanist Wager, and was the 2016 US Presidential candidate of the Transhumanist Party. He writes an occasional column for Motherboard in which he ruminates on the future beyond human ability.

Comments

comments

31 comments

  • Reynaldo Cahee 3 weeks ago

    digital signage outdoor

    Reply
  • Natosha Liggin 3 weeks ago

    live sex

    Reply
  • Demarcus Mullaney 3 weeks ago

    cool math

    Reply
  • Paulene Ker 3 weeks ago

    purificadoras de agua

    Reply
  • Celestine Horta 3 weeks ago

    airport car service

    Reply
  • snapmilfz 3 weeks ago

    snap milfs

    Reply
  • Casualty & Emergency Mgmt. Qatar 3 weeks ago

    I was very pleased to find this web-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

    Reply
  • Bed Census Management Qatar 3 weeks ago

    You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.

    Reply
  • In-patient ADT Management Qatar 3 weeks ago

    I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!…

    Reply
  • самолетен билет 3 weeks ago

    Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs everyday. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. I’d prefer to use some with the content on my blog whether you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link on your web blog. Thanks for sharing.

    Reply
  • полети до прага 2 weeks ago

    You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!

    Reply
  • make a logo for cheap 2 weeks ago

    Every few minutes Firefox tries to open a site. Because I just got a Trojan off my computer. So the link to the virus does not work anymore but Firefox keeps trying to open it. It says it cannot display this webpage. So how do I stop this?.

    Reply
  • едностайни апартаменти в софия продажби 2 weeks ago

    You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!

    Reply
  • self improvement 2 weeks ago

    Great post . . . I was just searching for something TOTALLY unrelated and came across this page. Definitely like the site and added it to my feedly to follow!

    Reply
  • Jon Anxin 2 weeks ago

    Great post . . . I was just searching for something TOTALLY unrelated and came across this page. Definitely like the site and added it to my feedly to follow!

    Reply
  • Earl Guenette 2 weeks ago

    hotel spa

    Reply
  • Tamra Corley 2 weeks ago

    1/2/2017 @ 21:16:29 Like the website– very user-friendly and lots to explore!

    Reply
  • sexstory 2 weeks ago

    We are building a large collection of sex-related stories, easy to navigate, categorized, without advertising. Anyone can have us publish their sex stories, for free. The best freesexstories for you.

    Reply
  • read my essay out loud 2 weeks ago

    171711 591762This web site is my inspiration , really excellent layout and perfect subject matter. 391839

    Reply
  • Jon Anxin 1 week ago

    Great post . . . I was just searching for something TOTALLY unrelated and came across this page. Definitely like the site and added it to my feedly to follow!

    Reply
  • teen cum slut 1 week ago

    We are building a large collection of phoenix sex-related stories about slut com,sluts in public,slut daughter and slut confessions teen cum slut easy to navigate, categorized, without advertising. Anyone can have us publish their sex stories, for free. The best teen sex stories for you.

    Reply
  • Johana Crepeau 1 week ago

    free porn

    Reply
  • Ismael Hooser 7 days ago

    DOLCE E GABBANA

    Reply
  • subwaysurfersgame.net 7 days ago

    If I publish my articles to my school paper are they copyrighted or do I have any ownership over them?

    Reply
  • subwaysurfersgame.net 7 days ago

    Hi! I really need some help and ideas for my creative writing assignment. We have to mimic the Canterbury Tales by Chaucer. We have to have 5 diverse characters (so far I have a brunette young woman who is a musician from NJ) and they are going on a pilgrimage to NYC. They have to be diverse based on gender, class, race, and occupation and where they are coming from. Then they have to each tell a story. I am having a lot of problems being creative with them. I really have no idea where to start. I would really appreciate any ideas. Thanks!.

    Reply
  • guillermo fredo austin 6 days ago

    He that winna be ruled by the rudder maun be ruled by the rock.

    Reply
  • French Door Prices 5 days ago

    593031 930598Oh my goodness! an remarkable post dude. Thank you Even so My business is experiencing dilemma with ur rss . Dont know why Unable to subscribe to it. Can there be anyone obtaining identical rss dilemma? Anybody who knows kindly respond. Thnkx 606379

    Reply
  • имоти продажби софия център 3 days ago

    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

    Reply
  • Argentina Mcneill 3 days ago

    victoria beckham dress

    Reply
  • Sarah Clarke 18 hours ago

    Dating when you are over thirty can seem tough. We all had plans to be married by 26 right? Well, thanks to 30 Plus Dating, 30 is the new 20! So make this new years start with a bang

    Reply

Add your comment

Your email address will not be published.